A new report by Israel Hayom assesses that Gaza militias backed by Israel have made virtually no impact against Hamas, and questions whether the policy of trying to replace the terror group with armed gangs is a sound strategy. Experts say the militias talk big but lack real influence, and that Israeli policymakers should reexamine the approach.
A report published by Israel Hayom on Sunday morning examines the effectiveness of Israeli-backed militias operating in the Gaza Strip against Hamas. According to the article, despite boasting of gains, the militias — described by the paper as armed gangs — have made almost no headway in reshaping the enclave or challenging the dominant terror group. The report cites experts who argue that the strategy is failing and that Israeli policymakers should be questioning whether arming local proxies to replace Hamas is a wise policy.
This assessment reflects the view that the militias, which have been active in the Strip since at least early June, have struggled to consolidate control or achieve meaningful military gains. The report's publication comes after weeks of reports of armed operatives from the 'Popular Committees' and other militia groups operating in northern Gaza, occasionally crossing into Hamas-controlled areas and issuing public challenges — but without lasting effect.
As The Zioneer reported on June 12, armed militia operatives were seen crossing the yellow line in northern Gaza, calling out 'Where is Hamas?' — but that incident appears to have been an isolated provocation rather than a strategic shift. The current analysis suggests that the overall effort is faltering, and that the quiet on the Gaza front, combined with intact Hamas control, may require a different approach from Israel.
- DevelopingAnalysis: Hamas is depleted but holding its fire — experts warn the quiet may not last
- DevelopingUnverified Gaza report claims militants killed were 'torn to pieces'
- DevelopingAnalyst warns current deterrence equation against Hezbollah is failing
- DevelopingReport: Israel conducts airstrikes in Gaza
Source and signal
A single-sourced dispatch is never rated Confirmed or Strong. Its Signal strengthens only when a second, independent source corroborates it.
- Internal intake