Political commentator Amit Segal (N12) reported Tuesday that the Attorney General did not issue a definitive legal opinion on whether to disqualify a Knesset candidate, instead telling the Central Elections Committee to 'weigh the disqualification request seriously.' Segal noted this appears to be the first time the Attorney General has refrained from taking a clear position on such a matter, and questioned the legal significance of the response.
Political commentator Amit Segal (N12) reported Tuesday that the Attorney General did not issue a definitive legal opinion on whether to disqualify a Knesset candidate, instead instructing the Central Elections Committee to 'weigh the disqualification request seriously.' Segal noted this appears to be the first time the Attorney General has refrained from taking a clear position on such a matter, and questioned the legal significance of the response.
Earlier today (Tue 14:12 Jerusalem), The Zioneer reported that the Attorney General had found cause to discuss disqualifying Balad chairman Sami Abu Shehadeh over alleged support for a terror organization. In subsequent updates, the Attorney General formally advised the committee that Abu Shehadeh expressed support for a terror group and urged the committee to seriously consider his disqualification, while stating there was no legal basis to disqualify most other parties and candidates.
The Attorney General's evolving position—from identifying cause for discussion to urging serious consideration, and now reportedly refraining from a definitive opinion—marks an unusual sequence in Israel's electoral legal process. The Zioneer has previously covered tensions between the government and the legal establishment over the role of the Attorney General in appointment and disqualification matters.
It remains unclear whether the Attorney General's response to Segal's query carries different legal weight than its formal recommendation to the committee, and how the Central Elections Committee will proceed with the disqualification request against Abu Shehadeh, who has denied the allegations.
4 developments
- DevelopingAmit Segal: Justice Amit avoids panel on military exemption, leaving Sohlberg to face criticism
- DevelopingAmit Segal: No such thing as a conservative justice who supports invalidating Basic Laws
- StrongKnesset legal adviser: No grounds to annul State Comptroller election results, but video evidence raises concerns
- StrongAG representative: lack of article disclaimer reveals candidate's real-time thinking
Source and signal
- Open-source intake